Bestselling Stuffed Animals For Newborn Babies

Bringing a new baby into the world is an exciting time, filled with dreams and preparations. Among the many items on your checklist, a soft, comforting stuffed animal often holds a special place. These gentle companions offer warmth, security, and a touch of whimsy to a newborn’s earliest days.

Choosing the perfect plush friend for your little one can feel overwhelming with so many options available. This curated list highlights some of the bestselling stuffed animals that are ideal for newborns. We’ve focused on safety, softness, and overall appeal, ensuring each pick is a wonderful addition to any nursery.

Whether you’re looking for a classic teddy bear or a unique sensory toy, you’ll find something here. Our selections range from budget-friendly finds to premium, heirloom-quality pieces. There’s truly a perfect snuggle buddy for every preference and price point. Get ready to discover your baby’s first cherished friend among these top choices.

—

1. Gund My First Teddy Bear

This classic teddy bear is designed specifically for newborns. Its ultra-soft, light brown plush material makes it incredibly comforting to touch and hold. It’s a timeless gift that babies often adore for years.

Perfect for welcoming a baby home, it’s a mid-range option that offers excellent quality. The embroidered “My First Teddy” on its foot adds a sweet, personalized touch, making it a memorable keepsake. It embodies the essence of a traditional, beloved stuffed animal for newborn babies.

2. Jellycat Bashful Bunny

Jellycat bunnies are renowned for their exceptional softness and distinctive floppy ears. Available in a variety of gentle colors, they instantly become a baby’s favorite cuddle companion. Their unique texture is a joy for tiny hands to explore.

This premium choice is perfect for parents seeking a luxurious feel and charming design. Its enduring popularity makes it a bestselling stuffed animal for newborn babies. The bunny’s sweet expression is sure to capture hearts.

3. Mary Meyer Putty Nursery Elephant

The Putty Nursery collection by Mary Meyer features incredibly soft, muted-tone animals. This adorable elephant is made with textured fabric, adding a sensory element for babies. Its gentle weight and floppy limbs are perfect for snuggling.

It’s an ideal choice for a serene nursery theme, offering a blend of comfort and style. This mid-range option is a fantastic gift for new parents. The elephant’s subtle design makes it a versatile addition.

4. Aden + Anais Muslin Lovey

Combining a breathable muslin blanket with a soft animal head, this lovey offers dual comfort. It’s lightweight, easy for small hands to grasp, and provides security. The muslin fabric is gentle against delicate skin.

This budget-friendly lovey is perfect for babies who enjoy sensory textures and security blankets. It’s a wonderful transitional object for soothing. The various animal designs add a playful touch to this functional toy.

5. Baby GUND Sleepy Seas Sound & Light Whale

This multi-sensory whale offers both a soft plush exterior and soothing features. It projects gentle lights and plays calming sounds, making it perfect for bedtime routines. Its smooth texture is safe for newborns.

Best for creating a tranquil nursery environment, this is a mid-range item. The combination of tactile and auditory stimulation makes it more than just a stuffed animal. It’s a fantastic aid for peaceful sleep.

6. Manhattan Toy Wee Baby Stella Beige Soft Doll

Wee Baby Stella is a soft, safe first doll for newborns. Her magnetic pacifier and gentle rattle inside add interactive elements. She’s made from ultra-soft fabric and has embroidered features for safety.

This doll is perfect for encouraging early nurturing play and sensory exploration. It’s a mid-range option that stands out from traditional stuffed animals. Her sweet size is just right for little arms to hug.

7. Lamaze Freddie the Firefly

While more of an activity toy, Freddie the Firefly features soft plush parts and crinkly wings. His bright colors and varied textures engage a newborn’s developing senses. He can be easily attached to strollers or cribs.

This budget-friendly item is great for stimulating visual and tactile development. He offers a blend of comfort and early learning opportunities. Freddie is a popular choice among bestselling stuffed animals for newborn babies.

8. Skip Hop Bandana Buddies Activity Toy – Monkey

This charming monkey offers multiple textures, a teether, and crinkle sounds. It’s designed to be easily held by tiny hands and can attach to various baby gear. Its soft body makes it a good cuddle friend.

Perfect for on-the-go stimulation and comfort, this is a mid-range product. The bandana serves as a teether, providing practical relief. This monkey is a playful and engaging option.

9. Bearington Baby Lil’ Snuggler Lamb

Bearington offers incredibly soft and sweet plush animals, like this gentle lamb. Its small size and plush material are ideal for a newborn’s first cuddles. The quality craftsmanship is evident in its design.

If you want a classic, sweet animal friend, this budget-friendly lamb is a wonderful choice. Its innocent expression makes it instantly lovable. It’s a soft, comforting presence in any nursery.

10. Cloud b Sleep Sheep On The Go

This compact version of the popular Sleep Sheep provides soothing sounds in a portable plush. It features a soft, cuddly exterior and plays gentle melodies or nature sounds. It’s perfect for travel or naps.

Best for parents seeking a comforting sound machine in a plush form, this is a mid-range choice. The small size (approximately 8 inches or 20 cm) makes it easy to take anywhere. It’s a functional and comforting companion.

11. Melissa & Doug K’s Kids Soft Activity Book – Who’s Hiding?

While not a traditional stuffed animal, this soft fabric book features plush animal characters and textures. It encourages interaction and sensory exploration from birth. The crinkly pages and squeakers delight babies.

This budget-friendly option is perfect for early developmental play and introducing animals. It combines the comfort of plush with the engagement of a book. It’s a wonderful alternative to classic stuffed animals for newborn babies.

12. Wubbanub Infant Pacifier – Dragon

Wubbanubs ingeniously combine a medical-grade silicone pacifier with a small, adorable stuffed animal. The plush animal makes the pacifier easier for babies to hold and less likely to get lost. The dragon is particularly whimsical.

Ideal for pacifier-loving newborns, this is a budget-friendly and highly practical item. The plush dragon offers a comforting presence. It’s a smart design that many parents swear by for soothing their infants.

13. Baby Einstein Octoplush Musical Octopus

This vibrant, soft octopus introduces colors and classical melodies. Each leg plays a different tune when squeezed, engaging a baby’s senses. Its plush body is perfect for snuggling.

This mid-range toy is excellent for sensory development and early musical exposure. It’s a fun and educational alternative among bestselling stuffed animals for newborn babies. The bright colors are visually stimulating.

14. Steiff My First Steiff Teddy Bear

For parents who appreciate heritage and quality, Steiff offers an exquisite “My First Steiff” bear. Made with premium, baby-safe plush, it’s designed to be an heirloom piece. It features the iconic Steiff “Button in Ear.”

This premium bear is perfect for a very special gift or a family tradition. Its exceptional craftsmanship ensures it will last for generations. It represents the pinnacle of luxury in stuffed animals for newborn babies.

15. Bunnies By The Bay Bud Bunny Bye Bye Buddy

This charming security blanket and plush toy combo features a sweet bunny head. Its ultra-soft, velvety fabric is incredibly gentle against a baby’s skin. The blanket portion provides a comforting tactile experience.

A mid-range option, it’s great for providing a sense of security and comfort. The bunny’s embroidered features are safe for newborns. It’s a lovely choice for a baby’s first lovey.

16. Fisher-Price Soothe & Glow Seahorse

This soft, plush seahorse glows with a gentle light and plays eight lullabies and ocean sounds. Its comforting features help soothe babies to sleep. The texture is soft enough for cuddles.

Best for bedtime routines, this mid-range soother is more than just a plush. The glowing belly and calming sounds create a peaceful environment. It’s a popular choice for helping newborns drift off.

17. Wild Republic Cuddlekins Stuffed Animal – Sloth

Wild Republic offers a range of realistic yet incredibly soft stuffed animals. Their sloth is a particular favorite, featuring a gentle expression and huggable body. It’s made with high-quality plush materials.

This budget-friendly sloth is perfect for parents looking for a slightly more unique animal friend. Its soft fur and friendly face make it an instant favorite. It’s a charming and distinctive choice.

18. Aurora World Miyoni Lying Fox Plush

Aurora World’s Miyoni collection features beautifully realistic and super soft animals. This lying fox plush has detailed features and a wonderfully soft texture. It’s designed for gentle snuggles.

This mid-range fox is ideal for a baby’s nursery with an animal or woodland theme. Its lifelike appearance combined with its plush comfort is unique. It’s a lovely addition to any collection of stuffed animals for newborn babies.

19. Gund Animated Flappy the Elephant Plush

Flappy the Elephant is an interactive plush that sings and plays peek-a-boo with his ears. While some interactive features are for slightly older babies, his soft plush body is still comforting for newborns to hold. He provides early visual and auditory engagement.

This premium plush is great for entertaining and comforting. The animated movements can captivate a baby’s attention. It’s a bestselling stuffed animal for newborn babies that grows with them.

20. B. toys by Battat – Woofer Hound Dog

This adorable hound dog plush is made with various textures, including corduroy and soft fabric. His floppy ears and friendly face make him a lovable companion. He’s lightweight and easy for little hands to grasp.

A budget-friendly option, Woofer is perfect for sensory exploration and cuddles. His unique design makes him stand out. He’s a charming and durable choice for a baby’s first dog.

21. FAO Schwarz 12-inch Bear with Bow

FAO Schwarz offers classic, high-quality plush toys, and this 12-inch (30 cm) bear is no exception. With its soft fur and traditional design, it’s a timeless friend for any newborn. The simple bow adds a touch of elegance.

This mid-range bear is perfect for those who appreciate classic charm and quality. It’s a wonderful gift that can be cherished for years. This bear is a quintessential example of bestselling stuffed animals for newborn babies.

22. Taggies Soft Blanket with Animal Head

Taggies blankets are known for their numerous satin loop tags, which babies love to rub and explore. This version includes a soft animal head for added comfort and play. It’s made from incredibly soft fabric.

This budget-friendly lovey is excellent for tactile stimulation and soothing. The tags provide a unique sensory experience for little fingers. It’s a popular choice for comforting and engaging newborns.

23. Zookiez Slap Bracelet Stuffed Animal – Monkey

This unique plush combines a soft monkey with a slap bracelet mechanism. While the slap feature is for older kids, the monkey itself is soft and cuddly for newborns. It can easily attach to cribs or strollers.

A budget-friendly and fun choice, this monkey offers a playful twist. The ability to “hug” onto things makes it versatile. It’s a creative option among bestselling stuffed animals for newborn babies.

24. Jellycat Odell Octopus

Beyond bunnies, Jellycat’s Odell Octopus is another immensely popular choice. Its eight soft, curly tentacles are perfect for a baby to grasp and explore. The plush body is incredibly squishy and comforting.

This premium octopus is perfect for sensory play and a touch of unique charm. Its distinctive shape makes it a standout. Odell is a beloved and frequently chosen stuffed animal for newborn babies.

25. Mary Meyer Taggies Character Blanket – Lion

Combining the sensory appeal of Taggies with Mary Meyer’s soft textures, this lion blanket is a winner. Its gentle lion face and numerous tags provide comfort and engagement. The soft fabric is ideal for newborns.

This mid-range item is perfect for babies who enjoy tactile discovery. It offers both the security of a blanket and the appeal of a plush toy. It’s a wonderfully comforting and stimulating choice.

—

Last Words

Choosing the perfect stuffed animal for a newborn is a truly special decision. Each of the options on this list brings its own unique blend of comfort, safety, and charm. From the classic appeal of a Gund teddy bear to the sensory delight of a Jellycat octopus, there’s a beloved companion waiting for every little one.

Remember to consider what features matter most to you and your baby. Whether it’s ultra-soft textures, soothing sounds, or early developmental features, these bestselling stuffed animals for newborn babies offer exceptional quality and appeal. You truly can’t go wrong with any of these top selections. Take a moment to explore their current prices and availability on Amazon, and find the perfect plush friend to welcome your new arrival.