Bestselling Plush Toys For Newborns

Welcoming a new baby into the world is an incredibly special moment. As you prepare their nursery and gather essential items, selecting the right plush toys is a delightful task. These soft companions offer comfort, stimulate senses, and become cherished keepsakes for years to come.

Finding the perfect plush toy involves considering safety, material, and developmental benefits. Our curated list of Bestselling Plush Toys For Newborns highlights a wonderful variety of options available today. We’ve explored different styles and price points to help you choose.

Whether you’re looking for a soothing comforter, an engaging sensory toy, or a classic cuddly friend, there’s something here for every little one. This article aims to present an honest review of excellent products. You’ll find options from budget-friendly choices to more premium selections.

Each product on this list has earned its spot due to its popularity, quality, and suitability for newborns. We encourage you to explore these fantastic plush toys. Doing further research will help you find the ideal match for your baby or as a thoughtful gift.

—

1. Manhattan Toy Winkel Rattle and Sensory Teether Toy

This iconic toy is a true multi-sensory marvel designed for little hands. Its captivating loops are soft and pliable, perfect for grasping and mouthing. It’s an excellent choice for developing fine motor skills from day one.

The vibrant colors and lightweight design instantly engage a newborn’s curiosity. A hidden rattle provides gentle auditory stimulation. This makes it a top product for early sensory exploration.

It’s ideal for newborns who are just starting to explore their world through touch and sound. Parents appreciate its easy-to-clean surface. This makes it a practical option for everyday use.

Consider this a mid-range price point item, offering exceptional value. Its unique design and developmental benefits make it a bestseller. This toy is a perfect first plush for any baby.

2. Baby GUND My First Teddy Bear Stuffed Animal

A classic choice, the Baby GUND My First Teddy Bear is synonymous with comfort and tradition. This ultra-soft plush bear is designed specifically for newborns, featuring embroidered eyes for safety. There are no small parts to worry about.

Its gentle, huggable form makes it an immediate favorite for snuggles. It’s a wonderful companion for quiet moments in the crib or stroller. This teddy is perfect for creating lasting childhood memories.

This teddy bear is an excellent gift for baby showers or as a “welcome home” present. It comes in various soft colors, fitting into any nursery decor. Its timeless appeal ensures it remains a beloved toy.

Positioned at a mid-range price, its enduring quality and brand reputation make it a worthwhile purchase. The My First Teddy is truly one of the best plush toys to introduce to a new baby.

3. Jellycat Bashful Bunny Stuffed Animal

The Jellycat Bashful Bunny is renowned for its unbelievably soft texture and sweet, gentle expression. This premium plush toy quickly becomes a favorite comfort item for many children. Its floppy ears and soft fur are incredibly tactile.

It’s perfect for newborns seeking a plush friend that offers soothing comfort. The quality of materials used ensures it can withstand years of loving cuddles. This makes it a durable companion.

This bunny is a popular choice for parents wanting a luxurious and safe plush for their baby. It’s available in many sizes and colors, allowing for a personalized selection. It’s often chosen for its elegant design.

Falling into the premium price category, its exceptional softness and high-end feel justify the cost. Many consider this the top choice for a truly special first plush.

4. Lamaze Freddie the Firefly Stroller Toy

Freddie the Firefly is a beloved activity plush that offers a wealth of sensory experiences for newborns. This vibrant toy features multiple textures, crinkly wings, a squeaker, and a baby-safe mirror. It’s designed to stimulate various senses.

With a convenient clip, Freddie easily attaches to strollers, car seats, or activity gyms. This makes it an excellent companion for on-the-go entertainment. It keeps babies engaged during outings.

This product is perfect for encouraging exploration and discovery in young infants. It helps develop visual tracking, auditory awareness, and fine motor skills. Its many features make it a great learning tool.

Priced in the mid-range, Freddie offers fantastic value given its numerous interactive features. It’s one of the bestselling plush toys for encouraging early developmental milestones.

5. Mary Meyer WubbaNub Pacifier Holder – Elephant

The WubbaNub is a clever and adorable solution for keeping a pacifier close at hand. This plush elephant is permanently attached to a medical-grade silicone pacifier. It’s designed for safety and convenience.

Its soft, weighted animal body helps the pacifier stay in place. This makes it easier for babies to grasp and manipulate. It’s an ideal choice for newborns who use pacifiers frequently.

This product is perfect for parents looking to prevent lost pacifiers and add a cute companion. The elephant design is particularly popular, offering a comforting presence. It doubles as a small plush toy.

Considered a mid-range item, its dual functionality offers excellent utility. It’s a top buy for parents seeking both comfort and practicality in one plush package.

6. Cloud b Sleep Sheep On The Go Portable Sound Machine

While primarily a sound machine, the Sleep Sheep On The Go is also a soft, cuddly plush. It offers soothing sounds to help newborns drift off to sleep. This makes it a wonderful addition to any nursery.

This adorable sheep features eight different soothing sounds and melodies, including a mother’s heartbeat and nature sounds. It can be easily attached to a crib or stroller. This provides comfort wherever you go.

It’s best for newborns who benefit from white noise or gentle melodies to calm them. The soft plush exterior makes it a pleasant tactile experience. It’s a great choice for establishing sleep routines.

This product falls within the mid-range price bracket, offering advanced features in a plush form. Its combination of sound and softness makes it a bestselling item for sleep support.

7. Slumberkins Bigfoot Kin – Comfort and Self-Esteem Plush

Slumberkins offers unique plush creatures designed to promote social-emotional learning. The Bigfoot Kin, for example, comes with a storybook and affirmation card. It focuses on building self-esteem and confidence.

These soft, cuddly toys are more than just plush; they are tools for connection. They are perfect for newborns whose parents want to introduce emotional wellness concepts early on. The quality is exceptional.

This product is ideal for parents who value holistic development and gentle learning. The plush itself is incredibly soft and comforting, making it a lovely snuggle buddy. It’s a unique purchase.

Falling into the premium price category, Slumberkins offers a distinct blend of plush comfort and educational value. This makes it a top choice for thoughtful gifting.

8. Steiff Hoppie Rabbit Soft Toy

For those seeking a truly heirloom-quality plush, the Steiff Hoppie Rabbit is an exquisite choice. Steiff is renowned for its craftsmanship and safety standards. This makes their products a treasured first toy.

Hoppie Rabbit features ultra-soft plush fur and is designed with safety in mind for newborns. Its classic design and superior materials ensure it will last for generations. It represents the best in plush toys.

This rabbit is perfect for parents desiring a premium, timeless plush that can be passed down. It’s also an excellent gift for special occasions, symbolizing enduring love. The quality is unmatched.

As a premium-priced item, the Steiff Hoppie Rabbit is an investment in quality and tradition. It’s considered a top-tier product for discerning buyers. Its heritage adds to its appeal.

9. Carter’s Whale Plush Stuffed Animal

Carter’s offers a delightful range of soft, simple, and safe plush toys for newborns, like this adorable whale. Its gentle blue color and friendly face make it an instant charmer. It’s perfect for little hands to hold.

This plush whale is made from soft, baby-safe materials, ensuring it’s gentle against delicate skin. It’s a fantastic first friend for cuddling and quiet playtime. It promotes a sense of security.

It’s a great choice for parents looking for a straightforward, comforting plush without extra features. Its small size makes it easy for newborns to grasp and hug. This makes it a lovely addition to any nursery.

Priced in the budget-friendly to mid-range category, it offers excellent quality for its cost. This makes it an accessible and popular purchase for many families.

10. Wild Republic Cuddlekins Stuffed Animal – Lion Cub

Wild Republic specializes in realistic animal plush toys, and their Cuddlekins Lion Cub is perfect for little adventurers. While realistic, it remains incredibly soft and cuddly for newborns. Its lifelike features inspire wonder.

This plush lion cub is made from high-quality, durable materials. It’s designed to withstand countless hugs and imaginative play as the baby grows. It’s a fantastic way to introduce animals.

It’s ideal for parents who appreciate nature-themed toys and want to spark curiosity early. Its substantial size makes it a comforting presence in the crib or playpen. It’s a top product for animal lovers.

Falling into the mid-range price category, it offers a unique blend of realism and plush comfort. This makes it a bestselling choice for animal-loving families.

11. Warmies Junior Comfort Heatable Stuffed Animal – Bear

Warmies offer a unique blend of comfort and therapeutic warmth. This plush bear can be gently heated in a microwave, providing soothing warmth and a subtle lavender scent. It’s wonderful for calming newborns.

The gentle warmth can help soothe fussy babies or provide extra comfort on a chilly day. It’s also suitable for cooling in the freezer for minor bumps. This adds to its versatility.

It’s perfect for parents seeking a plush toy with an added therapeutic benefit. The soft, plush exterior makes it a lovely cuddle buddy even without heating. It’s a thoughtful purchase.

Priced in the mid-range, the Warmies bear offers more than just a cuddle. Its unique features make it a top product for comfort and sensory input. Always ensure it’s a safe temperature for baby.

12. Skip Hop Bandana Buddies Activity Toy – Fox

The Skip Hop Bandana Buddies Fox is an engaging activity plush designed to stimulate a newborn’s senses. It features multiple textures, a crinkle sound, a teether, and a mirror. It’s packed with discovery.

This adorable fox easily attaches to car seats or strollers with a universal loop. This ensures entertainment on the go. Its vibrant colors and patterns capture a baby’s attention.

It’s perfect for encouraging sensory exploration and developing fine motor skills. The included teether is a great feature for teething babies. This adds to its long-term usability.

As a mid-range priced item, it offers excellent value with its diverse range of features. It’s a popular choice among Bestselling Plush Toys For Newborns for its engaging design.

13. Gund Tinkle Twinkle Little Star Musical Plush

This adorable musical plush from Gund offers gentle melodies and a soft, comforting presence. Shaped like a star, it plays the classic “Twinkle Twinkle Little Star” tune when squeezed. This provides soothing auditory input.

Its ultra-soft material and sweet embroidered face make it safe and appealing for newborns. It’s perfect for lulling babies to sleep or providing a moment of calm. This makes it a truly comforting product.

This star is an excellent choice for parents looking for a simple, musical plush to add to their baby’s routine. Its gentle nature makes it a wonderful crib companion. It’s a lovely first musical toy.

Priced in the budget to mid-range, this musical plush offers heartfelt charm without a premium cost. It’s a bestselling item for its sweet simplicity and soothing melody.

14. B. toys by Battat – Loopsy Llama Stuffed Animal

The Loopsy Llama by B. toys is a wonderfully quirky and soft plush toy. It stands out with its unique design and delightful textures. This makes it a charming companion for newborns.

Made from high-quality, baby-safe fabrics, this llama is incredibly soft and huggable. Its whimsical appearance adds a touch of fun to any nursery. It’s a great conversation starter.

It’s perfect for parents who appreciate distinctive toys that encourage imagination. The llama’s soft body is easy for little hands to grasp and cuddle. This makes it a top choice for comfort.

Falling into the mid-range price point, the Loopsy Llama offers a blend of unique style and plush comfort. It’s a popular purchase for those seeking something a little different.

15. Melissa & Doug Burrow Bunny Plush

Melissa & Doug are known for their high-quality, classic toys, and the Burrow Bunny is no exception. This plush rabbit is exceptionally soft and designed for cuddles. Its floppy ears and gentle expression are endearing.

Made with durable materials, this bunny is built to withstand years of affection. It’s an ideal first plush for newborns, offering a comforting presence in the crib or playpen. It’s a truly lovely product.

It’s a great choice for parents seeking a traditional, well-made plush toy that offers simple comfort. Its classic design ensures it will never go out of style. This makes it a timeless gift.

Priced in the mid-range, the Burrow Bunny offers excellent quality and durability. It’s a bestselling item for those who value classic charm and robust construction.

16. Fisher-Price Deluxe Kick & Play Piano Gym (Plush Toys Included)

While primarily an activity gym, this popular Fisher-Price product often includes detachable plush animal toys. These soft, engaging characters are perfectly sized for newborn play. They offer sensory input.

The included plush toys feature crinkles, rattles, and different textures. They are designed to stimulate a baby’s senses when attached to the gym or used independently. This provides versatile play.

This product is best for parents looking for an all-in-one solution that grows with their baby. The plush elements offer early tactile and auditory engagement. They are a great introduction to plush toys.

Positioned in the mid-range to premium category for the full gym, the plush toys themselves offer great value. They are a wonderful addition to any baby’s play collection.

17. Aurora World Flopsie Plush – Baby Fox

Aurora World offers a vast collection of soft, realistic animal plush toys, and their Flopsie Baby Fox is particularly charming. Its gentle expression and soft fur make it an appealing friend for newborns.

This plush fox is made from high-quality, baby-safe materials, ensuring it’s soft to the touch. Its floppy design makes it easy for little hands to grasp and cuddle. This promotes a sense of security.

It’s ideal for parents who love animal-themed nurseries and want a cute, comforting plush. The fox’s small size is perfect for newborns to snuggle. It’s a delightful addition to any collection.

Priced in the budget to mid-range, the Flopsie Baby Fox offers excellent softness and charm. It’s a popular purchase for those seeking an adorable animal companion.

18. Gund Peek-A-Boo Bear Animated Plush

The Gund Peek-A-Boo Bear is an interactive plush toy that brings a classic game to life. With the press of a button, this adorable bear raises and lowers a blanket, playing peek-a-boo and speaking. This delights newborns.

Its soft, huggable body makes it a comforting presence, even when not playing. The bear’s gentle voice and movements captivate a baby’s attention. This encourages interaction and smiles.

This product is perfect for engaging newborns and encouraging early social interaction. It helps develop auditory and visual tracking skills in a fun way. It’s a truly unique plush.

Falling into the mid-range to premium price category, its animation and sound features offer great entertainment. It’s one of the best interactive plush toys for a newborn.

19. Manhattan Toy Lullaby Dino Soft Musical Pull Toy

This charming dinosaur plush from Manhattan Toy combines softness with a soothing musical element. Simply pull the ring, and a gentle lullaby plays, helping to calm and comfort newborns. It’s a delightful sensory experience.

Made with ultra-soft fabrics and featuring baby-safe embroidery, this dino is perfect for snuggles. It easily attaches to cribs, strollers, or car seats. This makes it a versatile companion.

It’s an excellent choice for parents seeking a musical plush that offers both tactile and auditory comfort. The friendly dinosaur design appeals to babies and parents alike. This makes it a wonderful gift.

Priced in the mid-range, this musical pull toy offers quality craftsmanship and soothing functionality. It’s a bestselling option for introducing gentle melodies to a newborn’s world.

20. Taggies Soft Blanket with Rattle – Puppy

While technically a blanket, Taggies are famous for their signature satin loop tags, which are incredibly appealing to newborns. This soft blanket often comes with a small plush puppy head and a gentle rattle inside. It’s a sensory delight.

The various textures and tags provide tactile stimulation, helping with fine motor development. The attached puppy plush offers comfort and a friendly face. This makes it a comforting product.

This product is perfect for newborns who enjoy exploring textures and need a soothing comfort item. It’s easy for little hands to grasp and manipulate. This makes it a top choice for sensory play.

Falling into the budget to mid-range price category, Taggies offer exceptional sensory value. It’s a very popular purchase for its comforting and engaging features.

21. Lamaze Captain Calamari Activity Toy

Captain Calamari is another fantastic multi-sensory plush from Lamaze, designed to engage and entertain newborns. This friendly octopus features crinkly tentacles, a squeaker, a teether, and a mirror. It’s packed with discovery.

With a convenient clip, Captain Calamari can be attached to strollers, car seats, or activity gyms. This ensures fun and stimulation wherever you go. It’s a great companion for travel.

This product is perfect for encouraging exploration and developing various skills in young infants. It helps with visual tracking, auditory awareness, and grasping. Its many features make it a great learning tool.

Priced in the mid-range, Captain Calamari offers excellent value with its diverse range of interactive features. It’s one of the bestselling plush toys for encouraging early developmental milestones.

22. Sigikid Beasts – “Grumpy Garth” Plush Toy

Sigikid Beasts are a collection of quirky, character-filled plush toys with unique personalities. “Grumpy Garth” (or similar character) offers a distinct, high-quality plush experience. It’s designed for comfort and imaginative play.

These premium plush toys are made with exceptional craftsmanship and soft, durable materials. They are safe for newborns and designed to be loved for years. Each toy has its own story.

This product is perfect for parents seeking a unique, artistic, and high-quality plush for their baby. Its distinctive appearance makes it stand out from typical plush toys. It’s a special purchase.

As a premium-priced item, Sigikid Beasts represent an investment in unique design and superior quality. They are a top choice for those looking for something truly special and long-lasting.

23. Boon Jellies Suction Cup Bath Toys (often paired with bath time plush)

While primarily bath toys, some brands offer plush bath toys or sets that include a small, soft element. If considering bath time, a soft, quick-drying plush animal could be an option. (Note: Boon Jellies are not plush, but I will pivot to a true plush bath toy).

Let’s consider a product like the Skip Hop Moby Bathtime Play Set which sometimes includes a soft washcloth animal, or a dedicated Baby Bath Plush Toy designed for water play.

A suitable alternative would be something like a Munchkin Float and Play Bubbles Bath Toy which sometimes have small plush-like characters inside, or the Green Toys Stacking Cups which are not plush. I need a plush toy.

Let’s re-select for a purely plush item.

23. Green Toys Stacking Cups (Not plush, re-evaluate)

My apologies, I need to stick to plush toys. Let me replace this with a suitable plush item.

23. Wee Gallery Organic Cotton Muslin Animal Lovey – Fox

Wee Gallery offers beautiful, minimalist organic cotton muslin loveys, often in animal shapes like a fox. These combine the softness of a security blanket with a small plush head. It’s perfect for newborns.

Made from 100% organic cotton muslin, these loveys are incredibly soft, breathable, and gentle on delicate skin. They provide comfort and a familiar scent for babies. This makes them a top product.

It’s ideal for parents who prioritize organic materials and a simple, elegant aesthetic for their baby’s toys. The small size and lightweight design make it easy for newborns to cuddle. It’s a lovely choice.

Priced in the mid-range, these organic loveys offer premium materials and thoughtful design. They are a bestselling choice for eco-conscious families seeking natural comfort.

24. Baby Einstein Glow & Discover Soft Cube

This soft activity cube from Baby Einstein is a multi-faceted plush toy designed to stimulate a newborn’s senses. It features crinkly fabrics, a mirror, textured surfaces, and vibrant colors. It encourages exploration.

The cube is lightweight and easy for little hands to grasp and manipulate. It introduces cause and effect with a gentle chime when shaken. This makes it an engaging product for early learning.

It’s perfect for encouraging tummy time play and developing fine motor skills. The diverse features provide plenty of visual and tactile stimulation. This makes it a great educational plush.

Falling into the budget to mid-range price category, this soft cube offers numerous developmental benefits. It’s a bestselling item for parents seeking an interactive and educational plush.

25. Lambs & Ivy Jungle Fun Elephant Plush

Lambs & Ivy creates charming nursery decor and accessories, including delightful plush animals like this Jungle Fun Elephant. This soft, cuddly elephant is designed with gentle colors and a sweet expression. It’s perfect for newborns.

Made from plush, baby-safe materials, it’s incredibly soft to the touch and safe for little ones to snuggle. Its moderate size makes it an ideal companion for cribs or play areas. It adds a touch of charm.

It’s a great choice for parents decorating a jungle-themed nursery or simply wanting an adorable, comforting elephant friend. Its gentle presence provides a sense of security. It’s a lovely purchase.

Priced in the budget to mid-range, this plush elephant offers quality and cuteness. It’s a popular purchase for its comforting design and nursery appeal.

—

Last Words

Choosing the best plush toys for newborns is a delightful journey, and this list offers a fantastic starting point. From the classic comfort of a GUND teddy to the sensory wonders of a Lamaze activity toy, there’s a perfect companion for every little one. We’ve highlighted a variety of products, each with unique features and appeals.

Remember, the goal is to find a plush toy that offers comfort, safety, and gentle stimulation. Whether you prioritize organic materials, interactive features, or simply an incredibly soft friend, you can’t go wrong with these bestselling options. Each product has been selected for its quality and suitability for the newest members of our families.

Consider your baby’s potential preferences and your own aesthetic. Then pick a plush that feels right for your family. We encourage you to click through and check current prices and availability on Amazon. A wonderful new friend awaits your little one. Happy exploring and happy purchasing!