Bestselling Plush Toys For Newborns

Welcoming a newborn into the world is an incredibly special time. Among the many preparations, selecting the perfect first toys is a joyful task. Plush toys offer comfort, security, and a gentle introduction to the world of textures and shapes for your little one.

Finding the best options can feel overwhelming with so many choices available. This curated list focuses on Bestselling Plush Toys For Newborns that consistently receive high praise. We’ve gathered a variety of soft companions, sensory toys, and comforting friends.

Our goal is to help you discover a wonderful product that perfectly suits your baby’s needs and your preferences. From budget-friendly finds to premium heirlooms, there’s a fantastic option here for every new parent or gift-giver. Let’s explore these top picks on Amazon.

—

The Top Plush Toy Picks for Your Little One

1. Jellycat Bashful Bunny
This iconic plush bunny is renowned for its incredible softness and charming, gentle expression. It’s an instant classic, making it a top choice for many families.

The Bashful Bunny is perfect for newborns due to its high quality and safe design. Its floppy ears and soft fur provide comforting textures for tiny hands to explore. This premium product quickly becomes a cherished companion.

2. Baby GUND My First Teddy Bear
A timeless classic, the Baby GUND My First Teddy Bear is designed specifically for infants. It features ultra-soft, huggable material and a sweet, embroidered “My First Teddy” paw pad.

This mid-range product is an excellent choice for a traditional first teddy bear. Its durable construction ensures it can withstand years of snuggles. Many parents buy this for its sentimental value and lasting appeal.

3. Lamaze Freddie the Firefly
Freddie the Firefly is more than just a plush toy; it’s a sensory adventure for newborns. This vibrant product features crinkly wings, a squeaker, multiple textures, and a baby-safe mirror.

It’s an ideal budget-friendly option for stimulating visual and auditory development. The convenient clip allows it to attach easily to strollers or car seats, making it great for on-the-go fun. This review often highlights its engaging features.

4. Mary Meyer Putty Nursery Elephant
The Putty Nursery Elephant by Mary Meyer boasts a unique, incredibly soft, “putty” texture that newborns adore. Its neutral color palette and simple design make it a stylish addition to any nursery.

This mid-range plush toy is perfect for providing gentle tactile stimulation. It’s designed to be incredibly soothing for little ones, offering a comforting presence. Its exceptional softness sets it apart.

5. Fisher-Price Soothe & Glow Seahorse
This glowing seahorse is a popular choice for helping newborns drift off to sleep. When squeezed, it emits a gentle glow and plays 8 lullabies and soothing ocean sounds for up to 5 minutes.

It’s a mid-range product perfect for establishing calming bedtime routines. The soft, plush exterior is comfortable for cuddling. Parents often buy this for its effective comforting features.

6. Cloud b Sleep Sheep
The Cloud b Sleep Sheep is a plush companion that doubles as a sound machine. It offers eight soothing sounds, including a mother’s heartbeat and ocean waves, to help babies relax.

This premium product is great for creating a peaceful sleep environment. It has two timer settings and a Velcro strap for easy attachment to a crib. Its quality sound options are a standout feature.

7. Manhattan Toy Wee Baby Stella Soft Doll
Introduce your newborn to their first doll with Wee Baby Stella. This soft, 12-inch (30 cm) plush doll has a magnetic pacifier and can wear adorable outfits.

It’s a mid-range option perfect for encouraging early nurturing play. Her soft body is safe for newborns, and she’s easily washable. This product is designed for gentle, imaginative interaction.

8. Slumberkins Snuggler (e.g., Unicorn)
Slumberkins Snugglers combine a soft plush toy with educational resources for emotional development. Each character comes with a storybook and affirmation card.

This premium product is perfect for parents who want to foster emotional intelligence from an early age. The unique concept and high quality materials make it a special gift. It’s more than just a toy; it’s a tool.

9. Steiff Hoppie Rabbit
For a truly luxurious and heirloom-quality plush, the Steiff Hoppie Rabbit is an exceptional choice. Made with the finest materials, it features the iconic “Button in Ear” trademark, signifying superior craftsmanship.

This premium product is ideal for those seeking a timeless piece that can be cherished for generations. Its exquisite quality and classic design make it a very special gift. It’s truly among the Bestselling Plush Toys For Newborns in its category.

10. Skip Hop Bandana Buddies Activity Toy (e.g., Fox)
The Skip Hop Bandana Buddies are engaging plush activity toys designed to delight babies. Each character, like the charming fox, features multiple textures, rattles, crinkles, and a teether.

This mid-range product is perfect for sensory exploration and fine motor skill development. It easily attaches to strollers or carriers, providing entertainment on the go. Its vibrant features are a big draw.

11. Bearington Baby Waggles Puppy
The Bearington Baby Waggles Puppy is a super soft, floppy plush dog with a comforting feel. Its gentle design and friendly face make it an instant favorite for newborns.

This budget-friendly product is a wonderful choice for a classic puppy companion. Its cuddly nature provides a sense of security for little ones. The quality of the plush is surprisingly good for its price.

12. Melissa & Doug K’s Kids Who’s Hiding? Activity Toy
This unique plush toy encourages discovery and interaction. Babies can lift flaps to reveal hidden animals, stimulating curiosity and fine motor skills.

It’s a mid-range product that combines soft plush with engaging activity elements. The bright colors and different textures are perfect for sensory learning. This review often praises its interactive features.

13. Aurora World Miyoni Lying Fawn
Aurora World’s Miyoni collection offers beautifully realistic plush animals. The Lying Fawn is incredibly soft and detailed, providing a gentle representation of nature.

This mid-range plush toy is perfect for parents who appreciate realistic animal designs. Its serene pose and ultra-soft material make it a comforting presence in the nursery. The attention to detail in this product is remarkable.

14. Warmies Microwavable Plush (e.g., Bear)
Warmies offer a unique blend of comfort: a soft plush toy that can be warmed in the microwave. Infused with dried French lavender, it provides soothing warmth and a gentle scent.

This mid-range product is fantastic for comforting fussy newborns or helping them relax. It’s perfect for snuggling during naptime or bedtime. The dual features of warmth and scent are highly valued.

15. Aden + Anais Security Blanket with Lovey (e.g., Star)
This security blanket combines a soft muslin square with a plush animal head, like a gentle star. It offers a comforting texture and an easy-to-grasp friend for newborns.

It’s a budget-friendly option that serves as a beloved comfort object. The breathable muslin is gentle against baby’s skin. This product is often praised for its simplicity and effectiveness.

16. B. toys by Battat – Stuffed Animal – Wee Jams Elephant
The Wee Jams Elephant is a soft, cuddly plush that plays gentle melodies. Its chunky, textured legs are easy for little hands to grasp and explore.

This mid-range product is perfect for sensory discovery and musical enjoyment. The soothing tunes and varied textures make it an engaging companion. It’s a fun way to introduce sound to your baby.

17. Cuddle + Kind Hand-Knit Doll (e.g., Penelope the Penguin)
Cuddle + Kind dolls are exquisite hand-knit plush toys with a mission. For every doll purchased, 10 meals are provided to children in need. They are crafted from premium cotton.

This premium product is ideal for those seeking a beautifully made, ethical toy. The unique designs and soft, natural fibers make them cherished companions. Their charitable aspect adds significant value.

18. Posh Paws Disney Baby Winnie the Pooh
Introduce your newborn to a beloved character with the Posh Paws Disney Baby Winnie the Pooh plush. This soft and huggable product brings the classic bear to life for little ones.

It’s a mid-range option perfect for fans of Disney and classic stories. Its familiar face offers comfort and a sense of nostalgia. This product is a wonderful first friend for any baby.

19. Gund Peek-A-Boo Bear
The Gund Peek-A-Boo Bear is an interactive plush toy that plays a game of peek-a-boo with your baby. It covers its eyes with a blanket and says phrases, delighting infants.

This mid-range product is perfect for engaging newborns and encouraging interaction. Its animated features bring joy and laughter, making it a popular choice. Many review its charming personality.

20. Wild Republic Cuddlekins Jumbo Elephant
For a larger-than-life companion, the Wild Republic Cuddlekins Jumbo Elephant offers impressive size and softness. Its realistic design and generous proportions make it a comforting presence.

This budget-friendly product is great for creating a cozy, animal-themed nursery. It provides a substantial, huggable friend for growing babies. The quality for its size is often highlighted in its review.

21. Bearington Baby Lil’ Snuggler Blanket (e.g., Lamb)
This adorable combination of a plush toy and a security blanket is designed for ultimate comfort. The Lil’ Snuggler features a soft animal head attached to a small, plush blanket.

It’s a budget-friendly product that provides both a friend and a comforting textile. Perfect for soothing and tactile exploration for newborns. The price makes it an accessible comfort item.

22. Carter’s Elephant Plush Toy
Carter’s is a trusted name in baby products, and their elephant plush toy lives up to the reputation. It’s incredibly soft, with gentle details perfect for tiny hands.

This budget-friendly product is a reliable choice for a simple, comforting plush. Its classic design and established brand quality make it a popular pick. It’s often bundled with other baby essentials.

23. Angel Dear Blankie (e.g., Llama)
Angel Dear Blankies are known for their incredibly soft, cashmere-like fabric. Each blankie features a unique animal character, like a sweet llama, attached to a small square blanket.

This mid-range product is perfect for providing soothing tactile comfort. The diverse range of animals offers plenty of choices. It’s a perennial top pick for newborn gifts due to its luxurious feel.

24. Skip Hop Hug & Hide Activity Toy (e.g., Owl)
Similar to the Bandana Buddies, the Hug & Hide Owl offers multiple textures, crinkles, and rattles. It also has a hidden baby mirror and a teether, providing a wealth of sensory experiences.

It’s a mid-range product designed to engage and entertain. The variety of features supports sensory development and keeps babies curious. It’s another excellent product for on-the-go stimulation.

25. Lamaze Jacques the Peacock
Jacques the Peacock is another vibrant, sensory-rich plush from Lamaze. It features bright colors, crinkly feathers, a squeaker, and multiple textures to explore.

This budget-friendly product is excellent for visual and auditory stimulation in newborns. Its clip makes it versatile for attaching to various baby gear. It continues the tradition of top Lamaze sensory toys.

—

Final Words

Choosing the best plush toy for a newborn is a personal journey, but you truly can’t go wrong with any of the fantastic options on this list. Each product offers unique features and benefits designed to comfort, entertain, and stimulate your little one.

Consider what matters most to you: is it ultimate softness, sensory engagement, a classic design, or a special product with a mission? There’s a perfect match among these Bestselling Plush Toys For Newborns. Remember that plush toys provide crucial comfort and security during these early developmental stages.

We encourage you to explore these wonderful choices further on Amazon. You can check current price details and read more customer review insights. Finding the right companion for your baby is a delightful experience. Happy purchase!